Infrastructure

Positives and negatives splitting monitoring between production and non-production systems (#SCOM, #SYSCTR)

A little while back I was asked a question that I wanted to spend some time on answering with more than a quick reply. The question is below:

Why do you suggest that a parallel SCOM implementation always be set up to monitor a Quality Assurance/Development environment? My manager is trying to lighten our footprint, and is wondering.

The following are my thoughts on the positives and negatives to having a QA/Development environment (or test environment as I will refer to it during this blog post) for OpsMgr/SCOM.

 

Positives:

  • A test environment is required to provide a way to test changes in monitoring before they occur in production. 
  • Monitoring can be developed in one environment, and then migrated into the production environment.
  • A test environment provides a way to test Cumulative Updates and new versions of Microsoft management packs before they are rolled into production.
  • The alerts that appear in the production environment are production actionable alerts.
  • When all systems are together in one environment, situations occur where overrides need to be created for specific sets of servers specifically because they are not production systems. IE: I don’t want any alerts on my test systems, but send an alert if they are offline. Maintaining separate environments removes this issue.

 

Negatives:

  • There is additional overhead required to maintain the additional OpsMgr environment (patching, resources required, etc).  [To minimize this overhead, an all-in-one OpsMgr environment can be used which while it does not replicate the full configuration of the production environment, it provides most of the benefits of having a test environment.]
  • Having a test environment means that there will be different consoles which will need to be used to monitor depending on whether the system is or is not a production system.

 

Thank you to Blake Wilson, Paul Johnson and Stephen Leuthold for their insights!

 

How about you, have you seen additional positives or negatives or have a different perspective on one list above? If so, please let me know by adding a comment on this blog post!

One Response

  1. Louis Oliver August 15, 2012

Leave a Reply

x

We use cookies to ensure the best possible experience on our website. Detailed information on the use of cookies on this site is provided in our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Further instruction on how to disable our cookies can be found there.